Thursday, October 23, 2014

SONORA SI Solves Water Crisis with ABCs

 Sonoran Water Wars

Solving Sonora's Water Crisis is as Easy 
as A, B, C, and D

Tom Barry

Hydraulic megaprojects will keep Sonora “competitive and sustainable” and create a “Nuevo Sonora,” according to Governor Padrés. To advance this vision of a new era of water-based growth and development, Padrés established Sonora SI (Sistema Integral) as a new semi-autonomous entity that would supervise some two-dozen water projects – with the clear priority being several dams, aqueducts, and irrigation projects.

Creating a new hydraulic society will be as easy as A, B, C, and D, according to Sonora SI. That’s Agua, Bienestar, Crecimiento, and Desarrollo

In this rosy scenario, new hydraulic infrastructure will ensure the delivery of water supplies (Agua), thus producing widespread well being (Bienestar), economic growth (Crecimiento), and development (Desarrollo).[i]

Elsewhere, a rising number of local and national governments, together with international institutions, are turning their focus away from megaprojects like dams. Instead they are turning their attention to resource-conservation and climate-adaptation strategies. There is also a new understanding of the integral connections between healthy ecologies and healthy societies and cultures.

But with its “integral systems” of infrastructure projects Sonora seems stuck in the old modernization paradigm. The narrow development and resource-use strategies of the past are not being reevaluated. In the New Sonora, social well being, for example, is still closely linked to growth and resource extraction.

Elsewhere, especially in arid zones, citizens and governments are reevaluating the costs and benefits of hydraulic megaprojects.  Evaporation rates and the destruction of river-based ecologies and cultures are being considered as part of cost-benefits assessments of water megaprojects.
The Sonora state government, however, hasn’t lost faith in hydraulic infrastructure solutions.

Sonora SI boasts that the state government is “reviving the hydraulic tradition of Mexico and the history of large waterworks projects in Sonora.” This “important hydraulic infrastructure sustains the life of the state and the development of its social, economic, and productive activities,” according to Sonora SI.

The working premise of Sonora SI for creating the state’s new hydraulic society is as simple as it is disconcerting: “Water will not be a limiting factor” not for “this generation or the coming ones.” Although acknowledging the onset of climate change and the multitude of water crises facing the state, Sonora SI has concluded that a recommitment to water megaprojects is the state’s only viable option.[ii]

Sonora SI describes itself / Sonora Si website.

Referring to its hydraulic projects, Sonora SI proclaims:

“In this way, water in Sonora will become the motor of our development. Water will make us much more competitive. Water will also ignite new industrial and commercial operations that will generate employment and opportunities.”

Whether this type of positive thinking about the future of water in the transborder region is visionary, as the Sonoran government claims, or fantastical is not a question that getting much consideration in Sonora – aside from small circles of academics and environmentalists. For the most part, Sonorenses are hoping that the government’s hydraulic interventions save them from a future of grim scenarios where desert cities and economies wither for lack of water.

The term sustainability does appear in the discourses of Sonora SI and Governor Padrés. But the term is never defined, and it is invariably connected to concepts such as competitiveness and growth. Whatever the rhetoric of Governor Padrés and Sonora SI, the reality is that over the past several years Sonora SI -- in close collaboration with Conagua and with federal funding -- initiated large water projects without first consulting affected communities or serious evaluating likely impacts on ecological systems.

What is more, neither the federal nor state government considered the possible adverse impacts on the indigenous communities -- Yaquis, Mayos, and Guajiríos – of Sonora SI’s dams and aqueducts. There was no prior consultation, as mandated by national and international laws and conventions, with the indigenous communities whose land and water will be affected by these megaprojects. The three water megaprojects prioritized by Governor Padrés -- Independencia aqueduct, Revolución aqueduct, and Pilares dam – all deeply impact the ancestral and legally established rights of these indigenous peoples who have long depended on the flows of the Yaqui and Mayo Rivers.

The modernization paradigm embodied in the water megaprojects of Sonora SI has also excluded any broader pre-project discussion of how the bienestar of healthy communities is closely related to the health of the environment.
Scholars and environmentalists variously describe this connection between societies and the environment as biocultural diversity, biocultural evolution, cultures of habitat, or cultural sustainability.[iii]

Water planners in Sonora and elsewhere in the transborder West would do well to consider the links between healthy societies, cultures, and environments. By doing so, governments would likely avoid igniting water wars.  They might also help prevent more of type of socio-environmental disasters – often related to water use patterns and water shortages -- that are occurring throughout Sonora– from the river valleys to the coastal plains, from the cities to endangered rural communities. 

Scholars at the Colegio de Sonora examined the issue of water for indigenous communities in Sonora. Their report observed: “One can observe the pattern of dislocation of indigenous people from their traditional homeland and from their natural resources, and that conflicts over water for subsistence are becoming increasingly severe – all of which exacerbates the vulnerability of these communities and the disintegration of their traditional biocultural frameworks.”[iv]

"Orgullo de Sonora," Gobierno de Sonora's 
map of Native Indigenous Territories

Dimensions of Sonora’s New Hydraulic Society

There are four major thrusts of the water megaprojects of Sonora SI: Dams, aqueducts, water-treatment plants, improving potable water systems, and increasing reach of irrigation networks.[v]


* Providing new sources of water to urban centers in desert and in water-depleted deltas, including Hermosillo, Alamos, Huatabampo, Etchojoa, Navajoa, and Nacozari de García.

* Sonora SI is also overhauling the Río Yaqui-Guaymas aqueduct and battery of pumps that supply it even as agrochemical contamination and salinization of the soil worsen.

* Aqueducts will be built to conduct water from existing dams, notably from El Novillo on the Yaqui River and from Mocúzari on the Mayo River, the Independencia and Revolución aqueducts, respectively. According to Sonora SI’s vision, “Aqueducts are indispensable to distribute water equitably and responsibly among all Sonorans.”


* In some cases, new dams will be constructed, including the Bicentenario (Pilares) dam on the Mayo River and a few much-smaller dams and embalses including the Centenario dam near Narcozari de García and in the remote Las Trincheras area near Altar in the state’s northwestern territory (where there are new gold mining operations).

Water-Treatment of Waste and Residual Water

* Provide new sources of water or better quality water to Hermosillo, Guaymas, Nogales, Puerto Peñasco, and Navajoa by constructing water-treatment plants.

Drinking Water Infrastructure Projects

* Building a desalinization plant in the tourist town of San Carlos.

* Overhauling water-delivery systems in Cananea and Puerto Peñasco.

Expanding and Improving Drylands Agriculture

* Assist the agricultural sector throughout western Sonora by improving irrigation canals (including in Yaqui and Mayo deltas, and outside Guaymas), by new dams that stop flooding in the monsoon season, and by expanding the “agricultural frontier” in Sonora.

* Providing water to all Sonorans in an “equitable and responsible” way will not involve any reduction of water to the agricultural sector – which consumes 92.3% of Sonora’s water. There will be no reduction in agricultural production in the state, states Sonora SI. 

Moreover, the hydraulic projects will “open new frontiers” to cultivation. In particular, the waterworks program will expand the irrigation districts that that currently draw on the Mayo and Fuerte Rivers in the southern corner of the state – bringing as much as 73,000 hectares into cultivation.

No doubt that Sonora SI and Governor Padrés are right to identify water as the state’s main challenge. Yet the picture that Sonora SI paints of a state that is moving forward to improve the lots of its residents and to overcome the water crises that besiege the state seems far removed from the reality of many Sonorenses – particularly the poor and indigenous.

Yaqui men gather for tribal meeting at Vícam Estación, 
site of Yaqui blockade of Highway #15 / Photo by Tom Barry

[i] Sonora SI, “Acueducto Independencia,” Fondo de Operación de Obras, August 2012, at:
[ii] Sonora SI, “Acueducto Independencia,” Fondo de Operación de Obras, August 2012, at:
[iii]  Luque, Diana et al, “Pueblos indígenas de Sonora: el agua, ¿es de todos?” Región y Sociedad, No.3, 2012. For an excellent treatment of this biocultural framework for sustainability (with field studies of Seris and Tohono O’, see: Gary Paul Nabhan, Cultures of Habitat: On Nature, Culture, and Story (Counterpoint, 1997). For a broader treatments, see, among others: E. Boege, El patrimonio biocultural de lost pueblos indígenas, Mexico, INAH, 2008; Luisa Maffi, On Biocultural Biodiversity: Linking Language, Knowledge and the Environment, Smithsonian Institute Press, 2001.
[iv] Luque, Diana et al, “Pueblos indígenas de Sonora: el agua, ¿es de todos?” Región y Sociedad, No.3, 2012.
[v] Sonora SI, “Folleto Sonora SI,” at:

No comments: